
The crisis is here. Trump is in full-throttle crazy mode. On top of climate change, biodiversity collapse, and everything else, now we have this. What do we do now?
The most urgent task we face, in my humble opinion, is avoiding a “hot” civil war — avoiding large-scale violence, of the kind that we saw in the first American Civil War of 1861-1865. This is the possibility that Peter Turchin (discussed below) has raised — and as far as I know, he’s one of the few public figures who has done so.
The resistance to Trump is acting responsibly. But large-scale violence is not a far-fetched possibility. The Trump administration is already acting violently, though (so far!) it’s not lethal violence and is happening on a relatively limited scale. At least the violence is not lethal, as far as we know: we don’t know exactly what happens to people who get deported to El Salvador, including that one guy who got deported by mistake.
Don’t worry, it’s just the immigrants! (And the scientists losing their funding, the government workers losing their jobs, and the foreign tourists being detained by immigration.) It has also taken the form of institutional violence — breaking laws, undermining science, as well as supporting others who are committing lethal violence elsewhere (Ukraine, Gaza). This institutional violence doesn’t directly kill anyone, but paves the way for actual physical violence or sanctions existing violence.
And what happens if the Supreme Court backs Trump up on all this foolishness? Or the Court doesn’t back him up, but he defies the court? Will we just continue to rely on “free elections” in a system already heavily rigged in favor of the fascists?
Does anyone have a plan here? And where exactly is all of this leading? In 1858, it would have probably seemed incredible that the United States would shortly be engaged in large-scale violence that would kill hundreds of thousands of people. We need to think about this before an even bigger crisis is upon us, so that we can act effectively and nonviolently.
The need for an agenda
The other day on Facebook, I saw a graphic that said something like, “They wanted 1933 Germany; let’s give them 1788 France.” On doing a search, I found that you can actually get T-shirts with this slogan on (where else?) Amazon.com and Etsy! Sometimes the years vary a bit; it can be “1930s Germany,” “1939 Germany,” “1788 France,” or “1790s France.” One T-shirt has helpfully put a graphic of a guillotine.
Uh, I don’t think this is quite the approach we want.

They’re on the right track. Sure, we need revolutionary change. But we need to do better than the French Revolution. Have you guys ever studied, like, history? The French Revolution also led to a lot of bloodshed. Perhaps some of those nobles had it coming. But not everyone deserved the death penalty. And in the end, even other revolutionary leaders and other worthwhile people were killed as well — Georges Danton, Antoine Lavoisier, Olympe de Gouges, Lucile and Camille Desmoulins, for example.
And for what? After the revolution devoured a lot of its children, we then have Napoleon and an effective dictatorship. After that, Napoleon launches wars all across Europe that kill millions of people. And in the end . . . Napoleon is defeated, the pre-revolutionary French borders are restored, and we still have a King in France. Nice work, guys.
So exactly what do we want to achieve, anyway?
We need an agenda — and you don’t have to call it “revolutionary” if you don’t want to. But it has to be deeper than just restoring the status quo ante of last October. Merely going back to October leaves all the structural-demographic factors that made Trump possible in the first place; it does nothing about climate or inequality; after a short interlude, the crisis will just recreate itself in a different form. We need to think further into the future.
We were already in a crisis, long before Trump got into office. Trump’s election has just intensified the impact and grabbed everyone’s attention. Trump, or someone like him, was the product of social and demographic forces, and that’s what we need to address.
Avoiding large-scale violence
Those of you who have read my stuff know that I’m a great admirer of Peter Turchin, even though I don’t agree with absolutely everything he says. He seems to have totally nailed our current crisis, by interpreting it with actual data. I am trying to figure out why his latest book End Times isn’t flying off the shelves right now. For extra credit, check out his other books, especially Secular Cycles (about ancient societies) and Ages of Discord (about the United States) — which are a bit more technical, but still worth looking at.
Well, here’s the alarming thing. In a video from last November 19, he says that in the data that he’s collected on societies experiencing major crises (as we are right now), that in about 85-90% of the cases, the crisis is only resolved through some kind of “macro violence.” This would be a major outbreak of violence: civil war, revolution, political fragmentation, state break-up, or foreign invasion. And this is what happens most of the time — the default expectation, not something that “might” happen.
Turchin backs off this conclusion a bit: he points out several ameliorating factors which decrease the odds of this sort of disaster. He winds up concluding that the odds of disaster are more like 50%, not 90%. That’s certainly an improvement! But I’d feel a lot better if we could increase the odds to better than a coin flip.
Turchin mentions these ameliorating factors that make violence less likely:
1. The severity of these kinds of crises has declined over time; in the past centuries, we seem to be learning from our mistakes.
2. Stable institutions, such as democracy, also help. (Though “democracy” didn’t save us in 1860; the American Civil War occurred right after a fairly free election.)
3. There is no longer a “youth bulge” (a large percentage of the population 20-29 years old), as we saw in the America in the 1960s, and in the recent “Arab Spring.” Many revolutionaries are young people without prospects.
4. While there are a lot of unhappy people, very few are totally desperate. Even the homeless do not typically starve to death in the United States, though obviously their situation is more perilous than if they were housed.
Turchin sees the ultimate problem to political instability as dealing with a “top-heavy” social structure: basically, too many rich people (because in the United States, wealth confers power and elite status). So his advice is to “shut down the wealth pump.” The “wealth pump” is the process whereby the rich get richer. It is the rich who have the most disposable income to invest in the first place, and they also have the time and resources to research how to do it.
This suggests an obvious agenda to address both the immediate and structural causes of instability and violence:
1. “Shut down the wealth pump.” We know how to do this, but it’s politically difficult. Structurally, you could go back to the tax structure of the 1950s, that is, the top tax bracket would be about 90%. You’d probably need to do more than that, but that’s a good place to start.
2. Get the homeless off the streets and into housing. Ideally, a minimum or basic income for all adult citizens, or something equivalent (some have suggested a job guarantee). As a bare minimum, do as Mexico has done: increase the minimum wage, and peg it to inflation. (The real, inflation-adjusted US minimum wage has declined steadily since 1968.)
3. Strengthen our governmental institutions. For one thing, undo the Citizens United decision. This has had an obvious destabilizing effect on our society, because it enables those who already have money (the rich, like Zuckerberg, Bezos, and Musk) to gain even more money, by getting political power and manipulating the legal system and the Supreme Court makeup to their benefit.
4. Eliminate the problems that the wealth pump has already created, such as the makeup of the Supreme Court and gerrymandering. Probably the relatively easiest way to do this is to pack the court. Impeachment and removal for blatantly misreading the plain language of the Constitution, the theoretically correct method, is too hard; and constitutional amendments wouldn’t address the basic problem, because justices could still find a way to misinterpret anything.
5. Strengthen our intellectual institutions, notably universities and scientists. We could fully fund climate research, just for starters.
NOW you have a revolutionary agenda.
Is this all too controversial? People may blanch at several points, saying that this is just all too much too soon. I don’t think so. For example, I don’t think you’ll be able to strengthen science, at this point, without addressing wealth inequality and the makeup of the Supreme Court. Too many rich people with lawyers and political connections just don’t like science.
Dealing with climate and limits to growth will be quite difficult
But, incredible as it may seem, even all this still isn’t enough. We still have climate change and limits to growth. If you eliminated inequality, Citizens United, and gerrymandering, that would certainly help. It might even be enough, because with a strengthened democracy and strengthened scientific institutions, we should be able to figure out what to do about climate and everything else.
To be able to deal with climate and environmental challenges, we need full public understanding of what is happening, and something like a consensus of the American people about what we need to do. If we re-establish democracy, but only after large-scale violence, then consensus on climate will be much more difficult, to say the least.
What the climate movement needs to realize is that a massive build-out of renewable energy resources, the centerpiece of the proposed Green New Deal, is going to be more difficult than most of us imagine. It will require what many will regard as “sacrifices” from the American people. According to Vaclav Smil, getting to worldwide net-zero carbon emissions (much less 100% renewable energy from wind, water, and solar) will likely require 20-25% of the GDP of the advanced countries. Smil assumes, realistically it seems, that there will be cost overruns and that many poorer countries will not really be able to help very much, leaving the bulk of the job to the advanced industrial economies.
25% of GDP? That’s a level of commitment that we haven’t seen since the Second World War, when the country united into order to defeat Japan and Germany. That was also a time when the car industry shut down, almost half of our vegetables were grown in backyard “victory gardens,” and many consumer items were just not available. Are we ready for that level of commitment?
In fact, if we looked at these problems in detail (which we should!), we would likely find that “net zero emissions” is just the beginning of what we need to do. The impact of livestock agriculture is systematically and consistently underestimated in climate assessments. Drastically reducing meat as well as fossil fuel consumption, which over 15,000 scientists have urged, is also necessary. We cannot regard climate as a stand-alone problem. This will require a complete readjustment of our whole culture.
There will be other “limits to growth” type issues that also need to be addressed — soil erosion, water shortages, and biodiversity collapse, for example. Our agricultural system is not just unsustainable, it is massively unsustainable. These other problems, in the long run, may be more serious than climate change; and they will require the same, or greater, level of commitments.
We cannot really do this unless we have something like a consensus in our political life that this is the way forward. These environmental problems are all solvable (see Embracing Limits for details), but getting to a consensus on this point can only be made more difficult if we have another nasty episode like the previous American Civil War of 1861-1865. We still haven’t dealt fully with issues raised in that conflict; we don’t need another one.
We need to think carefully about how we proceed with our current crisis so that we are able to address the next one: how to deal with the real environmental issues that we should have addressed 50 years ago.

I definitely think avoiding Civil War II is a grand idea. I don’t care for a 50/50 chance of avoiding “macro-violence” or even a much lower likelihood. As for the need for reforming agriculture and eating habits, I agree; but how do we prevent Big Mac consumption short of an environmental disaster that shakes them to their foundations? They really want those burgers and chicken wings! Lab grown meat?